because our wood-fired bagels are baked fresh daily, our flavors are always rotating! If you want to ensure you get your favorite, give the shop a call to make sure we have it in stock for the day.
Bagels
plain
everything
wheat
wheat everything
spicy everything
sesame
poppy
onion
english muffin
french toast
kimmelweck
Cream Cheeses
plain
scallion
dill
garden veggie
jalapeno
garlic and herb
honey walnut
raspberry
salmon
vegan plain
Specials
The Jersey
1 egg, american cheese, taylor ham, and salt/pepper/ketchup
The Hot Honey Egg
1 egg, cheddar cheese, bacon, scallion cream cheese, and mike’s hot honey drizzle.
Breakfast
The Classic
1 egg, american cheese, bacon or sausage or ham
The Maple
1 egg, cheddar cheese, sausage, and maple syrup drizzle
The ADK
honey walnut cream cheese, 1 egg, cheddar, ham, and bacon
The Power-Up
almond butter, bananas, and honey drizzle
The Nova
dill cream cheese, capers, tomatoes, red onions, and acme smoked salmon
The Western
1 egg, cheddar cheese, bacon, red+Green peppers, red onions, chipotle mayo
The Nice n' Spicy
1 egg, pepper jack cheese, pickled jalapenos, bacon, and sriracha
The Spicy Vegan
vegan plain cream cheese, avocado, red peppers, red onions, frank's hot sauce, and a beyond meat patty.
The Basic Lox
plain cream cheese and acme smoked salmon
The United
avocado, cheddar cheese, 1 egg, and bacon
Lunch
The New Yorker
1 egg, Swiss cheese, pastrami, and spicy brown mustard
The Cranberry
turkey, lettuce, sliced green apples, cheddar, honey mustard and cranberry mayo
The Clark
horseradish mayo, rare roast beef, red onions, and cheddar cheese
The Super Veggie
garlic hummus, sprouts, tomatoes, cucumbers, spinach, and red onions
The Pizza Bagel
red sauce and mozzarella (pepperoni added for additional charge)
The TBR
Turkey, bacon, ranch, lettuce, roasted red peppers,and cheddar cheese
The Caprese
Turkey, spinach, tomato, fresh mozzarella, balsamic reduction and pesto mayo
The BLT
bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo
Our bagels are baked fresh daily.
Wood-fired,
never frozen.
Meet the Staff
Meg and Luke
owners
manager
Sophia
supervisor
Syd
Chloe
Dee
Jeremiah
head baker
Ron
head oven operator
Dan
Christine
Kathy
Nick
baker
Jonathan
baker
Taylor
Catering
Jen
Meg
Phin
Hannah
Interested in working with us?
send a resume and your availability to info@waterstreetbagelco.com.
We now do catering!
Please take a look at the available options below before submitting a catering request form (located below the menu)!
A 10% catering fee is applied to all catering orders over $100. Thank you.
- P L A T T E R S -
Large Lox Platter
"Just the basics" PLatter - $60
comes with two dozen bagels of your choice, sliced and arranged on a platter. Also comes with one plain cream cheese, and two flavored cream cheeses.
"lil' bit of lox" PLatter - $69.50
comes with 1.5 pounds of acme smoked salmon, as well as cucumbers, tomatoes, onions, and capers, all sliced and arranged on a platter.
feeds 8-12 people
"lots of lox" PLatter - $115
comes with 2.5 pounds of acme smoked salmon, as well as cucumbers, tomatoes, onions, and capers, all sliced and arranged on a platter.
feeds 15-20 people
deli meat PLatter - $110
comes with 10oz each of sliced turkey, ham, and rare roast beef, cheeses (american, swiss, pepperjack), and a small veggie platter (lettuce, sliced onions, sliced tomatoes). also includes pickles and assorted condiments.
All sandwiches can be changed to your needs/dietary restrictions.
Lunch sandwich platter- $9.50 per person
all sandwiches are sliced in half and displayed on a platter. choose from the following sandwiches: caprese turkey, tbr, cranberry, blt, super veggie, or the clark.
feeds 15-20 people
Deli Meat Platter
Lunch Sandwich
Platter
- S A L A D S -
FRUIT SALAD (S)$52 / (L)$90
HAND-CUT SEASONAL FRUIT, INCLUDING WATERMELON, CANTELOPE, PINEAPPLE, STRAWBERRIES, BLUEBERRIES, AND GRAPES.
Small feeds 10-15 people, large feeds 20+ people.
Fall harvest salad - $40
mixed greens, sliced green apples, crumbled goat cheese, toasted walnuts, and a housemade honey-dijon vinaigrette.
Feeds 10-15 people.
summer berry salad - $40
mixed greens, sliced strawberries, blueberries, crumbled goat cheese, toasted walnuts, and a balsamic vinaigrette.
Feeds 10-15 people.
Egg salad - $12 per lb.
tuna Salad - $16 per lb.
chicken salad - $16 per lb.
Serves 8-10 people.
Fruit Salad (S)
Fall Harvest
- G R A B N' G O -
"JOE-TO-GO" COFFEE - $22
comes with cups, lids, and all of the fixings.
BUTTER (8OZ) - $4
PLAIN CREAM CHEESE (8OZ) - $5
FLAVORED CREAM CHEESE (8OZ) - $6
sALMON CREAM CHEESE (8OZ) - $7
Summer Berry